Drama
featured
Review: ‘The Social Reckoning’ is a Disappointing Follow-up that Fails to Live Up to the Legacy of Its Predecessor
October 7, 2026Ben MK
|
Few movies have enjoyed the widespread cultural impact of The Social Network. But when you consider the pedigree of talent of involved in director David Fincher's 2010 masterpiece, it shouldn't come as much of a surprise. From Fincher himself to screenwriter Aaron Sorkin, composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, and star Jesse Eisenberg, there were many reasons why the film chronicling the rise of Facebook and trials and tribulations of its founder, Mark Zuckerberg, was such a bonafide success. And with The Social Reckoning, Sorkin is endeavoring to duplicate that success, as he steps into the role of both writer and director to tell the next chapter in the Facebook saga. Beginning in 2019, the story follows New York Times investigative reporter Jeff Horwitz (Jeremy Allen White) and Facebook data scientist Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison), two people with a mutual interest in exposing the truth, who find themselves on a collision course after Jeff begins digging into Facebook's questionable metrics. Bolstered by the company's shift to "meaningful social interactions," Facebook engagement has skyrocketed through the roof, while toxicity and hate speech on the platform have also seen a noticeable uptick in numbers. But what could be the root cause behind all of this? And what could Mark Zuckerberg (Jeremy Strong) be hiding? Despite the best efforts of Facebook executive Teddy Bennett (Billy Magnussen), Jeff's investigation manages to pique the interest of Frances, who's been trying with no luck to bring her own concerns about the company's algorithms to the attention of her superiors and co-workers. So when Jeff reaches out to her in an attempt to secure a credible source for his article, he unwittingly stumbles upon a treasure trove of internal documents corroborating the company's willful negligence in putting its entire user base directly in harm's way. Fast forward to 2021, and with the grim veil cast by the COVID-19 epidemic having recently just lifted and Zuckerberg preparing to testify in front of Congress about Facebook's prioritization of profit over user safety, the effect of the fallout from Frances' whistleblowing and Jeff's article has hit an all-time high. Little do any of them realize that another infamous historical event is just around the corner — the January 6th Capitol Riots. And unlike the egregious accusations Facebook has faced in the past, many of the rioters happen to have been radicalized through the platform and used it to coordinate the attack, a fact that will prove instrumental in damning the company in the eyes of Congress and anyone tuning in to see the testimonies. Will this end up being the final nail in the coffin of the ubiquitous social media platform? Or will the company continue to algorithmically promote misleading and oftentimes hateful content under the guise of being pro free speech, further fanning the flames of a global digital wildfire while also fattening its own proverbial pocketbook? Suffice to say, the real-life events on which The Social Reckoning is based speak volumes for themselves. Yet, while its critically acclaimed predecessor, The Social Network, managed to turn a series of relatively dry legal proceedings into one of the most compelling and edgy movies of the last two decades, the same can't be said of Sorkin's half-baked companion piece. Instead, what audiences are presented with here is a stunningly baffling film that portrays the majority of its characters as either bumbling idiots or sarcasm-challenged buffoons, inserting, for some inexplicable reason, The Office-style humor into most of its scenes and dividing its narrative into unnecessary chapters that ultimately do nothing to propel the story to its anticlimactic and clichéd conclusion. It all adds up to a movie that wouldn't even pass muster on its own. And when compared with Fincher's far superior tale, the shortcomings of this ill-advised follow-up only become all the more glaring. Make no mistake, it's not as if there isn't a story worth telling here. However, the main problem with The Social Reckoning isn't that it's an unnecessary sequel — it's that it goes about telling its story in a completely ludicrous and unintentionally hilarious way. Whereas the original was first and foremost a dramatic thriller with darkly comedic elements, Sorkin appears to be to positioning this follow-up as a straight-up comedy, writing jokes into every other line of dialogue and undercutting the seriousness of underlying subject matter at every turn. Whether you're a fan of the first film or not, it's enough to justify a reckoning at the box office. The Social Reckoning releases October 9th, 2026 from Sony Pictures. The film has an MPAA rating of R for language. Its runtime is 1 hr. 52 min. |
0 comments